Welcome to my consistently updated Crumbl Cookie Review page! I will be constantly adding new photos and flavor reviews as I continue to try more. ENJOY!
For anyone unfamiliar with Crumbl Cookies, they have a rotating list of weekly flavors! There are a few staple flavors that appear weekly but most of the flavors are unique to that week. As with anything that works, some flavors do reappear throughout the year but they are always adding new and improved flavors to their rotation.
These cookies are also extremely large portions and are very much shareable. I love grabbing a box of the new flavors and splitting them with my family and friends. We have found these cookies are easily cuttable into 4 slices per cookie which works great. That way everyone gets to try new flavors but still enjoy a full size cookie dessert! If you are hesitant to try the new flavors of the week, buy that four pack of the ones you want and split them up! There’s no shame in that.
I will be rating all my cookies in “peach points” x amount/10 and then will give a little feedback to accompany my review! These points are based on my PERSONAL preference, so please give these wonderful cookies a try if they fit your taste!
Be sure to download the Crumbl app on your phone before purchasing, you earn points for every purchase! You can also earn 10.00 Crumbl cash for every 100 points earned (1 point per every dollar spent).
I love using the app to order ahead, then you can park in a spot or walk into the store for pickup. Beware, the lines can get REALLY long in store so this is a very useful feature.
Also, if you ever need to look back on your orders to remember what cookie flavor you just loved, you can find that info in your “orders”. (That was a big help for me while providing you these reviews and reminding me of the accurate names for my favorite flavors!)
My first try and first box of Crumbl cookies!
From Top Left to Bottom Right
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip: Tastes like a classic oatmeal chocolate chip, which isn’t my favorite but I’ll eat it if offered.
6/10 Peach Points
Buckeye Brownie: Good for any chocolate/peanut butter lover. I don’t favor chocolate flavors – a little goes along way for me. This had ALOT of chocolate so if you love that, you will love this, I rated it lower since it’s not for me personally.
4/10 Peach Points
Chilled Cookies and Cream Milkshake: One of my absolute favorites. This cookie was sweet and tasty. I love the cookies and cream flavor for milkshakes so this reminded me a lot slurping one down. I would eat this again and again.
10/10 Peach Points
Chilled Sugar: A classic flavor that is often on the menu. A flavor I get every time I order if it is available no matter what. This cookie is always served chilled, the flavor profile is a unique sugar cookie. I have no way of describing it but I feel it has a unique sweet twist to a classic cookie flavor.
10/10 Peach Points
Cornbread: This one surprised me. I enjoy putting honey and butter on my cornbread when I eat it normally. So this really gave me the same taste of that. I really felt like they did a great job replicating cornbread in all ways. The touch of butter icing on top was a cute and delicious touch.
9/10 Peach Points
Milk Chocolate Chip: Not my favorite chocolate chip cookie to be honest. It is good, and if offered I will eat one of course, but I think I am just not a huge fan of any store bought or restaurant made chocolate chip cookies. I was spoiled growing up with my grandma’s homemade ones so nothing ever tastes as good as those! LOL
6/10 Peach Points
From Left to Right
Butterfinger: Tastes just like a Butterfinger. For sure had more peanut butter flavor than chocolate, so if you are a peanut butter lover and don’t mind having just a hint of chocolate to compliment that, I would try this out. Personally, this one didn’t make my list of favorites.
4/10 Peach Points
Churro: LOVE this flavor. Anyone who knows me will know that I am a cinnamon lover to my core. Any baked good with cinnamon, I am on it. Churro was a give for me and it met all my expectations. If you are like me and love cinnamon, or churros, you should for sure try this flavor if/when it reappears.
10/10 Peach Points
Circus Animal: Oddly enough tasted very similar to an actual Circus Animal cookie like the one placed on top. The icing had a marshmallow like quality and I don’t remember if that was the intended flavor or not but that is the taste it reminded me of. Either way, I enjoyed this cookie, but did feel like mine were a bit dryer than their usual cookies.
7/10 Peach Points
Chilled Sugar: *REPEAT REVIEW* A classic flavor that is often on the menu. A flavor I get every time I order if it is available no matter what. This cookie is always served chilled, the flavor profile is a unique sugar cookie. I have no way of describing it but I feel it has a unique sweet twist to a classic cookie flavor.
10/10 Peach Points
From Top Left to Bottom Right
Sugar featuring Circus Animal: *REPEAT REVIEW* Oddly enough tasted very similar to an actual Circus Animal cookie like the one placed on top. The icing had a marshmallow like quality and I don’t remember if that was the intended flavor or not but that is the taste it reminded me of. Either way, I enjoyed this cookie, but did feel like mine were a bit dryer than their usual cookies.
7/10 Peach Points
Blueberry Crumb Cake: Yummy yummy. This blueberry crumb cake reminded me a lot of these boxed blueberry muffins we used to make when I was a kid. They had a crumbl topping on them and were delicious. I loved the flavor and texture of this, I felt like it was fitting for the “crumb cake” it was imitating.
8/10 Peach Points
Waffle (with maple syrup): Another one that is kind of left field. This cookie reminded me of the cornbread one with the butter icing. However, this tasted just like a waffle. It was a must to drizzle with the maple syrup provided and enjoy it warm. I really liked how much this reminded me of the actual breakfast food I know and love.
8/10 Peach Points
Chocolate featuring Oreo: If you love Oreos then there is no doubt in my mind you would enjoy this flavor. I basically is a gourmet Oreo cookie. I personally enjoyed this more than regular Oreos because mine was warm and soft. I’m not usually a big fan of chocolate cookies, but this one had enough creamy icing for me to feel it was well balanced in flavors.
8/10 Peach Points
Chilled Sugar: *REPEAT REVIEW* A classic flavor that is often on the menu. A flavor I get every time I order if it is available no matter what. This cookie is always served chilled, the flavor profile is a unique sugar cookie. I have no way of describing it but I feel it has a unique sweet twist to a classic cookie flavor.
10/10 Peach Points
Peaches N’ Cream: I really enjoy peach flavors and I felt like this cookie had a very natural peach taste. The peach icing was light, creamy, and refreshing atop what I remember being a graham cracker tasting cookie. This was a great imitation of a pie crust with creamy peach filling.
8/10 Peach Points
From Top Left to Bottom Right
Hazelnut Churro: A delicious cinnamon cookie except this one is FILLED. Inside you have a delicious and warm hazelnut spread (like Nutella) which was a wonderful compliment to the cinnamon cookie. I enjoyed this almost as much as the churro cookie being the cinnamon lover that I am. I enjoy Nutella but didn’t need it inside to make me happy personally.
8/10 Peach Points
Cake Batter Blondie: A great, soft cake batter cookie with white chocolate chips and sprinkles. Let’s be honest, rainbow sprinkles really make anything pretty great! I like cake batter flavor so this cookie was delicious to me. The white chocolate chips were a great addition.
8/10 Peach Points
Buckeye Brownie: *REPEAT REVIEW* Good for any chocolate/peanut butter lover. I don’t favor chocolate flavors – a little goes along way for me. This had ALOT of chocolate so if you love that, you will love this, I rated it lower since it’s not for me personally. *ADDED REVIEW/POINT ADJUSTMENT* I had this cookie prior but originally there was a chocolate drizzle not a chocolate later like this one had. I enjoyed this version more, I guess because of the gooey layer of chocolate on top!
6/10 Peach Points
Milk Chocolate Chip: *REAPEAT REVIEW* Not my favorite chocolate chip cookie to be honest. It is good, and if offered I will eat one of course, but I think I am just not a huge fan of any store bought or restaurant made chocolate chip cookies. I was spoiled growing up with my grandma’s homemade ones so nothing ever tastes as good as those! LOL
6/10 Peach Points
Vanilla Sugar: Pretty much the same, from what I remember, as the classic sugar cookie… however I don’t think this one was chilled and it might have had an added “vanilla” flavor. I added my original sugar cookie review below just for your reference:
*REPEAT REVIEW* A classic flavor that is often on the menu. A flavor I get every time I order if it is available no matter what. This cookie is always served chilled, the flavor profile is a unique sugar cookie. I have no way of describing it but I feel it has a unique sweet twist to a classic cookie flavor.
10/10 Peach Points
Smores: I have to be in the mood for smores to enjoy the flavor. Fortunately for me, I was excited to try this flavor so the smores was great! I felt like it had all the qualities of a traditional over the camp fire smore but smashed into a delicious Crumbl cookie!
8/10 Peach Points
Birthday Cake (Valentines): Overall, this was a sweet, cake flavored cookie. Icing was almost cream cheese like if I remember correctly. I enjoyed it altogether and of course thought those heart sprinkles were cute for Valentine’s Day!
7/10 Peach Points
Cinnamon featuring Cinnamon Toast Crunch: Didn’t purchase this one but was going to! We had left overs at work and luckily that lined up with their cereal flavors release week! Yall should know by now just from these reviews alone that I am the cinnamon queen. If I am eating cereal my first pick is Cinnamon Toast Crunch. I loved this cookie. Icing was sweet, cinnamon cookie with Cinnamon Toast Crunch accents was tasty, it was everything I wanted in a cookie!
10/10 Peach Points